Patrick Smith is – along with Glenn Greenwald – pretty much the only reason I visit Salon.com these days. And it’s for columns like this:
In a way, choosing a favorite airport is akin to choosing a favorite hospital: Conveniences and accouterments aside, nobody really wants to be there in the first place, and the easier and faster you can get the hell out, the better. Which brings us to HKG’s most impressive and appealing feature: its rail connection to the city. The sleek, high-speed Airport Express train is literally only steps from the arrival and departure halls.
Now, let’s put aside for a moment that I don’t agree with that at all. The first part, I mean. But the second, man, it just boggles me that Dulles is still years away from getting a rail link to Washington.* Â And I am *completely* onboard with his BOS disdain:
Compare the best of Asia with, for example, my hometown airport, Boston-Logan. My commute to the airport by public transportation takes almost an hour and requires two changes, including a ride on the Silver Line bus, which, in addition to being at the mercy of automobile traffic, requires, at one point, that the driver step out and manually switch power sources to the bus.
Seriously, I spent at least 20 minutes looking for the entrance to the Silver Line at Logan, once. Â The signs said it was right in front of me, but there were just a bunch of (@#@#)( buses there. Â Christ. Â But to keep on the hatin’ theme:
Or how about JFK, where for hundreds of millions of dollars they finally got the AirTrain completed — an inter-terminal rail loop that can’t take you beyond the Queens subway. Heck, it can take 45 minutes, up and down a byzantine array of escalators, elevators and passageways, just to get from one terminal to another, let alone all the way to Manhattan.
I’ve done the the JFK-LGA transfer I don’t know how many times. Â And every time, in a $50-70 taxi ride. Â And not infrequently seeing the people that I’d been standing at the curb with at JFK alighting with me at LGA. Â Train line, anyone? Â Never mind getting to Manhattan (I understand helicopters aren’t entirely unreasonable). Â But here, too, Patrick has a comparison:
The distance from Shanghai airport to the city is about 20 miles — roughly the mileage from JFK to midtown. Shanghai’s bullet train covers this distance inÂ seven minutes.
This is why the Chinese are beating the US! Â Well, okay, not really. Â And I even had to take a cab from the end of the line to my hotel in Shanghai. Â But that seemed like the right thing to say. Â And maybe it’s even kind of true, in the end. Â The US can’t manage basic train connections from its international airpots to its effective capitol cities (IAD-DC, JFK-NYC), andÂ Â you can roll (levitate!) from PVG to Shanghai in 7 minutes.
It’s not all international roses, for sure:
To be fair, not every Asian terminal is so astoundingly convenient. Seoul, Bangkok and Taipei top a list of those without high-speed rail options.
My memory of Seoul? Â Well, I was 17 and had hair halfway down my back. Â Customs was, uh, interested in me. Â But my recent experience with Taipei’s airport certainly tracks his:
To top it off,Â everybody at Taoyuan was unfailingly polite, from the immigration officer to the man at the currency booth.
And isn’t this how it should be? In the end, an airport is more than just a place to kill time, more than an annoying conduit between ground and sky. It’s an expression, a gesture, a statement. It’s a welcome to, and a farewell from, the place you’re visiting or coming home to. In much of the world — not only Asia but throughout Europe as well — they have figured this out.
I am absolutely and completely onboard with his “in the end” thought. Â The idea that a significant international airport should well represent the country it’s a gateway to is the thing that keeps me railing against JFK (seriously, *that* is the first thing that people see when they arrive in the US?) and LAX (Just shoot it. Â Please.) while I’m in awe of YVR (Vancouver). Â Airports are amazing spaces for humanity. Â The US needs to do a better job of respecting and supporting that.
*Funny part: when I landed at HKG, it was the end of the longest flight I’ve ever been on – almost 17 hours from Newark. Â I stumbled to the car service, never once looking up. Â And on the way out, I was ten kinds of late, so ran through the terminal without once looking up. Â Yep, I somehow managed to retain zero memories about the biggest indoor space in the world, with the exception of some escalator that ended up taking me where I didn’t need to be (compounding the lateness). Â Well done!
I agree, JFK and LAX are just bad. IAD has been getting better, but it is still silly.
As for getting into Manhattan from DC and above on the East coast, I always use Amtrak now.
Unless it’s a connecting flight for an international trip, I’d never fly from DC to NYC. As you note, Amtrak is the answer, there.
(I like IAD’s new security/intake setup. I still think it’s 10 kinds of stupid that you can’t get a direct rail line into DC from there. Also? The moon buggies were the stupidest thing ever.)
Vivian J. Paige
What’s an airport?
That place you need to go. So you can go. No excuses.
It’s amazing what totalitarians can accomplish when they don’t have to worry about the inconvenience of public opinion.
Seriously, though, I agree with you about New York: I’ve never flown into or out of its airports. And won’t. And I agree about IAD’s “mobile lounges”: it ain’t a lounge unless it’s got a bar!
SFO has gotten a lot better in recent years.